Difference between revisions of "Talk:The Vestibule of Hell"
| (One intermediate revision by one other user not shown) | |||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
:There was a pretty ugly war over this a while back, where one user was pushing for just that and I was pushing to keep it. I felt that the Vestibule was unique enough to merit its own page, and that the Hell page should probably be trimmed down to a quick summary page since there's no actual branch called "Hell". In the end we asked for a Users vote and most people sided with preservation of Vestibule, but I haven't had the heart to actually trim Hell down yet... I think all the individual Hell pages could use some sprucing up and expanding, and dumping all that on one page would make it huge. Your thoughts?--[[User:MoogleDan|MoogleDan]] 16:29, 9 June 2013 (CEST) | :There was a pretty ugly war over this a while back, where one user was pushing for just that and I was pushing to keep it. I felt that the Vestibule was unique enough to merit its own page, and that the Hell page should probably be trimmed down to a quick summary page since there's no actual branch called "Hell". In the end we asked for a Users vote and most people sided with preservation of Vestibule, but I haven't had the heart to actually trim Hell down yet... I think all the individual Hell pages could use some sprucing up and expanding, and dumping all that on one page would make it huge. Your thoughts?--[[User:MoogleDan|MoogleDan]] 16:29, 9 June 2013 (CEST) | ||
::I figure we should at least keep the pages for the branches of Hell, since those are unique enough to deserve them. Mostly, I'd noticed that the Vestibule's information was pretty much covered on the Hell page; I figure we should either have a seperate article for the Vestibule and just a brief overview on the Hell page, or we could make the Vestibule its own section on the Hell page since it's not much of a branch on its own and it's the central access point for the rest of the hells. I'd be okay with doing it either way. [[User:Spudwalt|--spudwalt]] | ::I figure we should at least keep the pages for the branches of Hell, since those are unique enough to deserve them. Mostly, I'd noticed that the Vestibule's information was pretty much covered on the Hell page; I figure we should either have a seperate article for the Vestibule and just a brief overview on the Hell page, or we could make the Vestibule its own section on the Hell page since it's not much of a branch on its own and it's the central access point for the rest of the hells. I'd be okay with doing it either way. [[User:Spudwalt|--spudwalt]] | ||
| + | :::Oh, we DEFINITELY want to keep the pages for each of the branches, that seems a given. I feel pretty strongly that the Vestibule deserves its own page too; even if it's a short branch, it's pretty much the game's only required "Boss Fight". If both options are equal to you, I'd say trim down the Hell page to a quick summary page with links to all five. --[[User:MoogleDan|MoogleDan]] 19:16, 10 June 2013 (CEST) | ||
| + | ::::Okay, I guess I'll go do that. [[User:Spudwalt|--spudwalt]] 19:19, 10 June 2013 (CEST) | ||
Latest revision as of 18:19, 10 June 2013
Anybody else think we should just merge this with the Hell page? From what I've seen, all the information on this page is already there. --spudwalt 06:41, 9 June 2013 (CEST)
- There was a pretty ugly war over this a while back, where one user was pushing for just that and I was pushing to keep it. I felt that the Vestibule was unique enough to merit its own page, and that the Hell page should probably be trimmed down to a quick summary page since there's no actual branch called "Hell". In the end we asked for a Users vote and most people sided with preservation of Vestibule, but I haven't had the heart to actually trim Hell down yet... I think all the individual Hell pages could use some sprucing up and expanding, and dumping all that on one page would make it huge. Your thoughts?--MoogleDan 16:29, 9 June 2013 (CEST)
- I figure we should at least keep the pages for the branches of Hell, since those are unique enough to deserve them. Mostly, I'd noticed that the Vestibule's information was pretty much covered on the Hell page; I figure we should either have a seperate article for the Vestibule and just a brief overview on the Hell page, or we could make the Vestibule its own section on the Hell page since it's not much of a branch on its own and it's the central access point for the rest of the hells. I'd be okay with doing it either way. --spudwalt
- Oh, we DEFINITELY want to keep the pages for each of the branches, that seems a given. I feel pretty strongly that the Vestibule deserves its own page too; even if it's a short branch, it's pretty much the game's only required "Boss Fight". If both options are equal to you, I'd say trim down the Hell page to a quick summary page with links to all five. --MoogleDan 19:16, 10 June 2013 (CEST)
- Okay, I guess I'll go do that. --spudwalt 19:19, 10 June 2013 (CEST)
- Oh, we DEFINITELY want to keep the pages for each of the branches, that seems a given. I feel pretty strongly that the Vestibule deserves its own page too; even if it's a short branch, it's pretty much the game's only required "Boss Fight". If both options are equal to you, I'd say trim down the Hell page to a quick summary page with links to all five. --MoogleDan 19:16, 10 June 2013 (CEST)
- I figure we should at least keep the pages for the branches of Hell, since those are unique enough to deserve them. Mostly, I'd noticed that the Vestibule's information was pretty much covered on the Hell page; I figure we should either have a seperate article for the Vestibule and just a brief overview on the Hell page, or we could make the Vestibule its own section on the Hell page since it's not much of a branch on its own and it's the central access point for the rest of the hells. I'd be okay with doing it either way. --spudwalt
